Losing Touch

I showed up at my first dress rehearsal as a member of “The World of Mime,” my high school’s mime troupe, wearing the requisite costume: black turtleneck shirt, black tights, black ballet slippers. Mr. Lawrence, the drama teacher who led the troupe, asked me whether I was wearing a dance belt.

“What’s a dance belt?” I asked.

“It’s like a heavy-duty jockstrap,” he said. “What do you have on under there?”

“Just underpants,” I said uneasily. I didn’t mention that I had carefully dyed my tighty-whities black so they wouldn’t show through the tights.

“Beth! Ruth!” he called out to two veteran members of the troupe. (Ruth’s full name was actually Ruth Ann, but she’d resigned herself to being known simply as Ruth.) “Take him to the Capezio store and get him a dance belt!”

Ruth Ann was a senior, and thus had a car. Beth, a junior, was there for moral support. We were already friends, having worked on several shows together. I was totally comfortable with them, especially with Ruth Ann. She was warm and empathetic, the kind of person who would take your hand when she was talking with you. She and I both wrote songs, but hers were lovely, slow, and pensive, while mine were fast and funny. Each of us envied the other’s writing style. We once got to collaborate on a song for a musical, and the experience was an awakening — I’d never felt so totally embraced by another person. I was secretly, totally in love with Ruth Ann.

After a 15-minute drive, we walked into the dancewear store, and I approached the clerk at the counter. “I’d like to get a dance belt,” I said.

The clerk politely replied, “What size?”

I turned bright red. Both Beth and Ruth Ann literally doubled over in laughter. I stared at the clerk, not knowing what an appropriate answer would be. I eventually choked out, “Um, what sizes do they come in?”

Ruth Ann and Beth were laughing so hard that they could no longer make any sounds come out. “They go by waist size,” said the clerk.

Why do I remember this incident so warmly, instead of as a humiliating or traumatizing experience? I think it’s because — to dredge up a cliché for which I can’t find an apt alternative — Beth and Ruth Ann were laughing with me, not at me. We were totally comfortable with each other. We were theater people.

Theater people habitually touched, hugged, and emoted. Any of us could get on stage and be completely vulnerable, and it would be OK, because all of us had done it. And I’m sure that this capacity to be vulnerable grew out of the bond that comes from physical touch. This was a way of relating to people that I never knew was possible until I fell in with the drama crowd in high school.

The kind of contact that I came to value so much — my crush on Ruth Ann notwithstanding — wasn’t romantic, and it wasn’t sexual. It was pure warmth and trust, and it crossed gender lines. I remember rehearsing for a touring production of “The Wizard of Oz,” when I (as the Tin Man) and my friend Howie (as the Cowardly Lion) were being threatened by the Wicked Witch of the West. When the witch turned to me, I jumped into Howie’s arms. And when the witch turned to him, we immediately switched positions, with Howie jumping into my arms. It wasn’t planned; it just happened — a product of our being so tuned into and familiar with each other. The bit stayed in the show, and remained was one of my favorite moments.

After Ruth Ann graduated, the go-to person for transportation was a senior named Diane, who had a little red Volkswagen Beetle. There was one night — I wish I could remember where we were going — when nine of us squeezed into Diane’s car. Putting aside that most people of my generation are significantly larger than we were in high school, I can’t imagine anything like that happening today. I have a tendency to hug my friends, and a few of them are especially good huggers in return, but it doesn’t come close to the degree of ease and physical comfort that I had with my drama friends in school. It’s likely that I’ll never be in an environment like that again. What a loss.

Read Me 2 comments

Giving Voice

Royal Albert Hall (photo by Debra)

Debra and I went a few nights ago to an event at the Royal Albert Hall called “Letters Live,” in which noted actors (and a few non-actors — in this case, a completely unexpected John Kerry) read aloud from letters written by various correspondents over the centuries. The event takes place annually, and somehow is popular enough that the 5,000 seat venue was almost entirely sold out, but we weren’t sure whether we wanted to spend the money to grab up two of the few remaining seats.

“It’s a chance to visit the Royal Albert Hall,” I said.

“But it’s people reading letters,” said Debra.

“But one of the people is Benedict Cumberbatch,” I said. (Although the cast list is kept secret until the night of the event, Cumberbatch was an exception, and was featured prominently in the advertising.) “Have you heard his voice? I’d listen to him reading from the phone book.”

(In hindsight, I guess it’s time to retire that outdated cliché. When is the last time anybody saw a phone book? I should have said, “I’d listen to him reading Google search results.”)

In the end, we decided to go, and it was a mixed bag — some of the letters were less interesting than others, and some of the performers were less enthralling — but Cumberbatch was one of the standouts, assuming the personalities of three different people (one of whom was an American) from different times and places. His characterizations were so captivating that I didn’t even pay attention to the quality of his voice.

In a few of my earlier posts, I’ve alluded to my difficulty in processing spoken language. When listening to someone speak, I can focus intently on the meaning of the words, making sure I’m comprehending everything they say; or I can relax and just enjoy the voice, the manner, and the personality of the person doing the speaking. My tendency is to do the latter, which means that I often miss a lot of the content. A great performer can make those two aspects of speech so compelling and inseparable that I feel like I’m receiving it all in a single gulp. But unfortunately for my processing of everyday interactions, not everybody is Benedict Cumberbatch.

I remember driving from Princeton to my parents’ house on Long Island with my girlfriend at the time, Alex. She was telling me a long story and then stopped to apologize, saying “I guess I’m really going on, aren’t I?”

“That’s OK,” I said. “It doesn’t matter what you’re saying; I’m just comforted by the sound of your voice.” I meant that purely as an expression of affection, but she didn’t hear it that way.

“You mean that what I say isn’t important? That it’s all just babble?”

I quickly assured her that everything she said was indeed important, but I realized later that her anger was appropriate. I really didn’t remember anything about the story she told; I had just been delighting in the experience of being in the presence of Alex — the way she looked, the way she smelled, the way she sounded.

In recent years, I’ve come to realize that many of my relationships with people are similarly unbalanced. There have been many people that I’ve thought of as friends, but while each of them might think that our friendship centers around the things we say to each other, my perception is that our conversations are simply excuses for me to enjoy that person’s physical presence. And as much as I value honesty in a friendship, I can’t say so out loud, because that person is likely to (justifiably) react the way Alex did.

As a result, I’ve found myself largely withdrawing from the world of friendships. I think one of the reasons I’m so comfortable here in London is that everybody is a stranger, and I don’t have to pretend otherwise. When I strike up a conversation with a random person in a pub, it’s clear to both of us that what we’re saying is of no importance; we’re just appreciating the special moment of making a connection. And when there’s no connection to be had — as when I’m one of 5,000 people sitting and listening to the voice of Benedict Cumberbatch — I can guiltlessly sit back and enjoy the sensation.

Read Me 2 comments